21 Comments
User's avatar
Anna Davison's avatar

Scribbles that Matter are my go to - they do a version that is part bullet journal with dotted pages but also weekly and monthly spreads that you can make work for you. Thick paper suitable for a real pen too! I changes to something else this year and have regrets…..

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

Oh no! Planner regrets are a heartbreaker. Are you going back for 2026 or is that when you strayed?

Expand full comment
Anna Davison's avatar

I was going to go back to STM for my 2026 planner but now after reading the above I’ve just spent way too long on the Paper Republic website…. 🫣🫣😅

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

Paper Republic is total lushness.

Expand full comment
Grace Jeschke's avatar

Those look really useful and well-designed!

Expand full comment
Anna Davison's avatar

They are really good quality!

Expand full comment
Grace Jeschke's avatar

Sounds like you had an amazing time in England, Caroline! I'm looking forward to reading some of the books you recommended. I definitely turn to romance when I need to escape to a happier world (and still can), even though the good romances make me cry. I just need a book to devour.

Warning: Nerdy planner details below.

For 2025, I got the MiGoals(.com) planner for the second time. The first version I got several years ago had more blank unlined space in each weekly spread, and I was disappointed when there was just larger days. I like space to prioritize things I need to get down, without assigning them to a day. Like many planners, it has a monthly spread, and weekly spreads. Unlike many others, It has many pages in the beginning to help clarify and your goals for the year, and pages for short-term and long-term goals with steps, and quarterly review, as well as inspiring quotes. I don't use the planning pages very much, except some long-term goals and the "Rate Your Life" where you select a number for how satisfied you are in various areas (e.g., relationships, health, finances) and the beginning & end of the year. It's hardbound with two ribbons and mine is A5, so not the most portable.

This year I'm going to try minimalist/DIY. I already have a Laconic mostly-unused undated monthly calendar and undated gantt chart which I used for habit tracking/check-in. They are thin paperbound A5 notebooks, and the paper is sooo smooth so I'm thinking of adding a weekly calendar or non-calendar for notes and weekly schedules, or I could just use the blank pages in the back.

Of course, after a month or two, I may run for a planner with dates, as I did earlier this year (when I was only using a blank notebook).

And I may need to browse some of the other companies ...

Expand full comment
Grace Jeschke's avatar

It looks like all the recommended planners have similar space for goals and planning, so migoals is not so different. I guess it was the first time I actually ordered a planner rather than settle with whatever I could find in a store.

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

It sounds lovely! Once you know the format you like it’s so much easier to choose other options, if you want to try. I’m looking forward to having a peek at the migoals — thanks for the tip!

Expand full comment
Shizuka Otake's avatar

I've used the Hobonichi Weeks planner for the past 3 years. All I really do in a planner is right down appointments and a minimal to-do list. The funny thing is that even though the Weeks is small, I could do without the "100 dreams" and little extras in the back. They're sweet, but an even thinner planner would be my ideal.

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

It is a small one — really good option to carry with you. I can see not wanting the extras for that. Mine lives on my desk, so I can handle a few extra pages. 😍

Expand full comment
Cara Finnegan's avatar

When I first returned to paper planners, I tried some of the heftier ones with goals and lists and checkmark boxes for whether or not you had hydrated enough that day and decided: Nope. Then I tried out Mark+Fold after hearing about it on your podcast a few years ago and have never looked back. The Mark+Fold diary is exactly what I want - flexible and minimalist.

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

Such a dream, isn’t it?? I suspect I’ll go back to it for 2027. It’s so classy and simple.

Expand full comment
Annabel Youens's avatar

Merchant and Mills! Ack - a dream course!! Every envious.

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

It was SO WORTH IT. I definitely recommend the experience. I learned a lot, the staff was lovely and it was so fun to spend time with other sewing nerds

Expand full comment
Annabel Youens's avatar

Omg. The third book in my series will have to involve dressmaking…so I do “research” 🥳

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

YESSSSS

Expand full comment
Nicola's avatar

Honestly, I can barely bring myself to read this post because I know it will tempt me into buying yet more planners. What is it about planners that draws me in every single year so that I always end up buying several? (Rhetorical question, obviously!)

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

They are such a strong temptation! I almost broke down and bought the Mark + Fold after all while writing this because they have a linen edition that is truly stunning this year. Eeeeeee

Expand full comment
Nicola's avatar

A linen edition?!?! Please don’t tell me that! 😍

Expand full comment
Caroline Donahue's avatar

Oh yes with a beautiful TYPE ELEMENT. I am sitting on my hands as we speak. I feel your pain. 🤣

Expand full comment